An analysis of the differences between the western and east asian views on law and justice

Human Rights and Asian Values

It can even be insulting to tip because doing so is considered to be an affront to an employee's salary. He bids his students to look at his hands and feet, and quotes lines from the Book of Poetry to convey the idea that all his life he has been keeping his body intact as part of his duty to his parents.

So, the decision-in-ignorance models fairness, because it excludes selfish bias. Jainism may have roots dating back to the times of the Indus Valley Civilization. On the other side, one must be wary of oversimplifications of Western rights-oriented ethical codes.

Psychologists have been very interested in finding out the impact the type of culture has on the individual. The importance attached to li, to ritual propriety itself, indicates the Confucian appreciation for the role of culture and convention in enabling human beings to express ethical attitudes toward each another such as care and respect see Cua, for rich explorations of li in the thought of Xunzi.

As emerged above, one must distinguish between meaning and evaluational incommensurabilities. They also held that the Vedas were "eternal, authorless, [and] infallible" and that Vedic injunctions and mantras in rituals are prescriptive actions of primary importance.

The rain stopped during the mid-autumn night and the sky became clear again. Eastern culture encourages its people to gain control over their emotions and state of mind through meditation and practices the principal of virtue in all aspects of life.

In theory, the upperclassman serves as a mentor for the underclassmen, and it is the junior's duty to help out and support the senior members of the group.

Western interpreters have been unable to see this, argues Hansen, because they have imposed their own concerns with correspondence truth and metaphysics on the Chinese tradition. The revival of interest in Chinese metaphysics has partly been fueled by the perception that twentieth century physics has in fact undermined the strategy of giving determinate being ontological primacy Zukov, These arguments for greater compatibility between Chinese and Western ethics do not eliminate all significant differences between them on the subject of rights.

We proceed on the assumption that the others we are interpreting live in the same world as we do. Consider again the notion of wuwei and its illustrations in the Zhuangzi through stories of exemplary craft.

What were the main differences between the Eastern and Western Roman empires?

But a human being is, after all, not a machine made up of different parts. MacIntyre himself presents a possibility for resolving such conflicts in case one tradition continually fails in its attempts to address certain key problems or issues. May Sim argues that Aristotle's metaphysics of the soul supplies a substantial self that is both needed and presupposed by Confucius' virtue ethics.

But a human being is, after all, not a machine made up of different parts. At the same time, Zhong Ziqi, a woodsman had also stopped under the cliff to avoid the storm.

Difference Between East and West

He put the qin aside and got up. He put this thought into his music. One of the central interpretive problems concerning the Zhuangzi in particular is how to reconcile the skeptical themes about the limits of our concepts and theories with the recommendations for living in a certain way, since the recommendations are framed with concepts see Kjellberg and Ivanhoe,Hansen,and Wong, for a variety of interpretations.

In his painting, "The Last Supper," Da Vinci was able to illustrate the expressions and the mental states of each subject in the painting in a vivid manner and bring the subjects to life.

Particularist modes of reasoning in Confucianism parallel the Aristotelian notion of a phronesis or practical wisdom that depends significantly on knowledge of particulars acquired through experience. Confucianism lacks a comparable concept, given its assumption that the ethical life of responsibility to others and individual flourishing are inextricably intertwined Shun, Confucians are more willing to articulate their teachings in the form of principles, but such principles seem to function as designators of values or general considerations that ought to be given weight in judgments about what to do.

That model is not the same as a general principle that would deductively yield a judgment about what to do in the present situation. It is possible to argue that even if responsibility-frameworks are developed and institutionalized to provide genuine protection to dissenting individuals, they cannot provide as much protection as rights frameworks when individual interests seriously threaten communal or social interests.

Cash is not exchanged by hand. Company loyalty is valued, and promotions are often given on the basis of seniority. These artists all possess extraordinary painting techniques, but the styles of their paintings are completely different.

It also would eliminate certain utilitarians from having a morality: As mentioned above, Clineargues that insights from the Analects and from Rawls can be combined to produce a more plausible conception of how a sense of justice develops starting with the family. Shun could not interfere with the judge, who was acting on the law.

Philosophy and Cultural Difference, Honolulu: Even when it comes to medication, the approach is much more scientific. Daoist ethics are often cited as exemplars of substantial difference with the Western tradition.

Much of the value of Daoist ethics lies in its warnings against the constricting effects of conventional ethical codes, the blinkering of vision that comes with what we might otherwise regard as admirable integrity and dedication.

The appropriate resolution to each conflict depends very much on the situation. Actually the difference between the Eastern culture and the Western culture is not only reflected in how people from the two cultures view things differently, the difference can be seen in many different areas.

Western Ethics, on the other hand, has more of an emphasis on self and what is rationally or logically true. Furthermore, Western Ethics places more emphasis on law and justice, whereas Eastern Ethics states that one must do what is right and expected and the universe will take care of the rest.

There might still be a difference between Chinese and Western traditions with respect to which strains of thought become dominant or at least prevalent, but that difference does not appear to come under the heading of radical incommensurability.

Understanding East Asian-Western Differences and Similarities in These skewed self-views are sustained through an impressive array of intra- and inter- responded with a meta-analysis of. Differences Between East and West Discovered in People’s Brain Activity By Carey Goldberg Mar.

4, Facebook; East Asian cultures stress interdependence. When Easterners take in a scene, they tend to focus more on the context as well as the object: the whole block, say, rather than the BMW parked in the foreground.

echo more than. What are the differences between Western Culture and Eastern Culture? whereas western culture takes on a pragmatic and emotional approach in searching outside oneself through research and analysis. Difference Between Chinese Culture and Western Culture Difference Between Samurai and Ninja Difference Between East .

An analysis of the differences between the western and east asian views on law and justice
Rated 0/5 based on 81 review
Differences, Similarities & Intersections Between East and West | HubPages